![]() On the question of the ruling's impact, the actual fallout from Citizens United has probably been overrated. Nevertheless, the constitutional arguments made by the Court had more basis in text and precedent than the Roberts Court's five absolutely worst decisions. Indeed, on the very narrow question presented by the case-whether the federal government could suppress the broadcast of an anti-Hillary Clinton movie- Citizens United was arguably correct to answer "no." What makes the decision a bad one is that the Court went far beyond what was necessary to decide that issue. On this score, the First Amendment questions at the heart of campaign financing are genuinely difficult. Let's take the first criterion, plausibility. ![]() First, how plausible was the legal argument? And second, how negative was the policy impact of the decision? By these measures, Citizens United doesn't quite qualify as the worst work of the Roberts Court. So what were the five worst Roberts Court rulings? This list relies on two criteria. In fact, Citizens United arguably does not rank in the top five rulings handed down during the Roberts era. But the left's fixation on Citizens United overlooks many Roberts Court decisions that were as bad or even worse. After all, big money has the potential to disrupt virtually every aspect of the progressive agenda, from environmental regulations to the minimum wage and health care. Not only Senator Elizabeth Warren but Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton have consistently railed against the case as a symbol of the corporate takeover of democracy, and so have countless grassroots activists.Īll this makes sense given the extent to which wealthy interests have been permitted to dominate American politics and policy. FEC ruling is "one of the worst Supreme Court decisions in the history of our country." And this is not an instance where Sanders conflicts with the conventional wisdom of the party establishment either. In a by-now familiar applause line, Bernie Sanders told Democrats gathered at the Democratic National Convention last week that the Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United v.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |